Legally Speaking - Drunk Cyclist-dot-Busted
By Bob Mionske
Posted May. 15, 2003
Here’s an odd one for ya: Can someone get their driver’s license revoked for cycling while drunk? Is it illegal and, if so, what can they do to you if you are caught riding while intoxicated?(
I have to admit that at first, I didn’t think this question was really all that applicable to readers of this column. But, the more I thought about it, the more relevant it seemed. For instance, I’m sure many cyclists have attended a summer barbecue by bike only to partake in all that is offered before riding home. Then there is former 7-Eleven rider Alex Stieda (the first North American to don the Yellow Jersey in the Tour de France), who used to organize something called the “So you think you're tough” bicycle race in which participants had to consume a full beer every lap before continuing. Now, that race was held in British Columbia, and Canada is almost like a different country, so maybe that doesn’t count, eh?
I also personally recall at least one lightheaded and exciting ride home from a saloon at the end of a long hot day in the saddle. And then there is, of course, a site dedicated to this and other questions of excess at www.drunkcyclist.com and… well, enough said. (Actually, not enough said... a word of caution, don’t open that site at work or in front of your kids or mother, okay?)
At least eight states have determined that drunk cycling falls within their drunk driving statutes: California, Florida, Hawaii, New Jersey, Ohio, Oregon and Pennsylvania. Only a few have said the opposite, including Washington State, Illinois and Louisiana.
Let’s compare two states that didn’t have specific language. Florida said drunk cycling is the same as drunk driving and Illinois didn’t. Why?
Florida’s version is the current model traffic code language, Illinois’ is from the older, early 1980’s version. The same is true for their respective definitions of vehicle:
In Florida, a bicycle is a vehicle, while in Illinois a bicycle is treated as if it were a bicycle. Compare the judge’s decision in the two cases:
See what an incredible difference just a few words can make?
Can your license be revoked for drunk cycling?
Four states have heard court appeals where a bicyclist was both convicted of drunk bicycling and where the cyclist’s driver’s license was revoked: Hawaii, New Jersey, Ohio and Pennsylvania. Only Pennsylvania determined that a driver’s license could be revoked for a bicycling violation. The state’s commonwealth court said that:
On the other hand, a New Jersey court clearly stated the opposing argument when it upheld a cyclist’s conviction for drunk driving, but refused to suspend his driver’s license:
So, what’s the conclusion? It’s probably a legislative matter. Those states that put specific language in their code books prohibiting drunk cycling and permitting their license bureaus to revoke a drunk cyclist’s driver’s license will enforce it, and most of those that choose not to probably won’t.
If you are too intoxicated to drive a motorized vehicle, you probably should not ride a bicycle either. However, the idea of mounting a bike when you are too inebriated to drive a car is as old as the invention of motorized vehicles themselves and a Washington State court seemed to endorse this idea when it decided that a cyclist was not subject to the DUI provisions, explaining that drunk bicycling, in consideration of the lower traveling speeds and vehicle weight, in most cases, did not present the same risk to society.
(Research and drafting assistance provided by Bruce Epperson-law student-Nova Southeast University)
June 13, 2013
The Oregonian: Are Portland bicyclists showing signs of an unfortunate new trend? Dana Tims, The Oregonian By ...
June 7, 2013
WGME Portland, ME: Bicyclist claims TV personality tried to run his bicycle off the road PORTLAND (WGME) -- A ...
May 27, 2013
The Toronto Star: Most Ontarians want more bicycle lanes, survey shows Nearly three-quarters think cycling inf...
May 27, 2013
iol Motoring: Italians ditching cars for bicycles May 27 2013 at 10:31am By Amelie Herenstein Bicycles ar...